If you were hurt by a factory robot, a packaging line, a conveyor system, or any other piece of industrial equipment built overseas, you've probably assumed the manufacturer who designed and built the machine can simply be sued in California alongside everyone else involved in your injury. A new published decision from California's Fourth District Court of Appeal complicates that assumption — and it's already generating confusion among injured workers across Los Angeles County's manufacturing, logistics, and bottling corridors.
In Fanuc Corp. v. Superior Court, filed October 9, 2026, the appellate panel held that on the specific evidentiary record before it, a Los Angeles trial court lacked personal jurisdiction over the Japanese robotics manufacturer whose industrial arm was involved in a serious bottling-plant injury. The ruling is narrow, fact-bound, and does not decide what caused the injury or whether the robot was defective. But it is an important reminder that in product liability cases involving imported machinery, where you can sue is sometimes just as contested as who is at fault.
What Happened in the Underlying Case
The litigation arose from an incident at a Southern California bottling and packaging facility, where an industrial robotic arm — designed and manufactured by a Japan-based robotics company — allegedly struck or crushed a worker during a line changeover. The injured worker sued multiple defendants, including the equipment's domestic distributor, the plant operator, and the foreign parent manufacturer itself.
The manufacturer moved to quash service of the summons, arguing that California courts had no personal jurisdiction over it because the company did not directly sell, market, service, or maintain a physical presence in California. The trial court denied the motion, reasoning that the manufacturer's products reliably ended up in California through an established distribution network and that the company should have reasonably anticipated being haled into court here. The Fourth District reversed, granting the writ petition and ordering the trial court to quash service as to the manufacturer.
Why the Court Found No Jurisdiction
California courts apply a two-track analysis for personal jurisdiction over out-of-state (or out-of-country) defendants: general jurisdiction, which requires the defendant be essentially "at home" in the forum state, and specific jurisdiction, which requires the defendant to have purposefully directed activity at California connected to the plaintiff's specific claim.
No one seriously argued the Japanese manufacturer was "at home" in California, so the fight centered on specific jurisdiction and, in particular, the "stream of commerce" theory — the idea that a manufacturer who places a product into a national or global distribution chain should expect, and therefore accept responsibility for, that product ending up in any state where it causes harm.
The Fourth District held that the stream-of-commerce theory, standing alone, does not satisfy due process under controlling U.S. Supreme Court precedent (including the fractured J. McIntyre Machinery v. Nicastro line of cases that California courts continue to wrestle with). The panel found the record showed:
- The manufacturer sold the robot to an independent U.S. distributor outside of California, with no contractual requirement or incentive directing the product specifically into the state;
- The manufacturer did not design the robot specifically for the California market, advertise directly to California customers, or maintain sales, service, or repair operations here;
- The California sale and installation were arranged entirely by intermediaries, without evidence the manufacturer targeted, or even knew of, the specific California transaction in advance; and
- General availability of the manufacturer's products nationwide was not, by itself, "purposeful availment" of the privilege of doing business in California.
Because the plaintiff could not show the manufacturer purposefully directed conduct at California tied to this particular machine, the court concluded exercising jurisdiction would offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.
Why This Matters for LA-Area Injury Victims
Los Angeles and the surrounding Inland Empire and Long Beach port corridor host one of the densest concentrations of manufacturing, logistics, bottling, food processing, and warehouse automation facilities in the country. Much of the heavy equipment inside those facilities — robotic arms, palletizers, conveyor systems, CNC machines, injection molders — is designed and built overseas, often in Japan, Germany, South Korea, or China, and imported through layered distribution chains before it ever reaches a California factory floor.
When that equipment causes a catastrophic injury — crush injuries, amputations, traumatic brain injury, or worse — injured workers and their families often assume the original manufacturer is an obvious defendant. Fanuc is a reminder that naming the right defendants, and proving the jurisdictional facts to keep them in a California court, requires careful early investigation. Get that wrong, and months can be lost litigating a jurisdictional motion instead of the merits of the injury claim.
Hurt by Industrial Equipment in Los Angeles?
Jurisdiction fights can derail a product liability case before it even starts. Our team investigates the full distribution chain — manufacturer, importer, distributor, integrator, and employer — to identify every available defendant and build your claim correctly from day one.
✆ Call (323) 372-1216 — Free ConsultationWho Can Still Be Held Liable
Losing jurisdiction over the overseas manufacturer does not mean an injured worker is left without recourse. In most industrial injury cases, several other parties remain squarely within California jurisdiction and may bear independent liability:
- The U.S. distributor or importer — the entity that actually brought the machine into the United States and California, and that may have modified, configured, or marketed it for local use.
- The systems integrator or installer — the company that installed, programmed, calibrated, or integrated the robot into the specific production line where the injury occurred. Integration errors (improper guarding, defeated safety interlocks, incorrect programming of the robot's working envelope) are frequently the actual cause of factory robot injuries.
- The employer or plant operator — while workers' compensation generally bars direct negligence suits against an employer, third-party product liability and, in some cases, "power press" or specific statutory exceptions under Labor Code provisions may still apply, and a non-employer plant operator (if different from the employer) may be independently liable.
- Maintenance and service contractors — companies responsible for inspecting, servicing, or repairing safety guarding, light curtains, emergency stops, and interlocks.
- Component and safety-equipment suppliers — manufacturers of the specific sensor, guard, or safety relay that failed, who may have their own independent California contacts even where the robot manufacturer does not.
In many cases, the distributor or integrator has deeper, more direct California contacts than the overseas manufacturer — regular sales, service technicians stationed in the state, marketing aimed at California buyers — which can support jurisdiction even when the original manufacturer successfully avoids it.
Alter Ego and Agency Theories
Plaintiffs' counsel can also investigate whether the "independent" U.S. distributor is, in fact, a subsidiary or closely controlled agent of the foreign parent. If the parent manufacturer exercises sufficient control over the distributor's operations, pricing, marketing, or warranty service in California, an alter-ego or agency theory may allow jurisdiction over the parent despite the formal corporate separation — a fact-intensive inquiry that requires discovery into corporate structure, ownership, and day-to-day control.
Targeted Marketing and Direct Sales Evidence
Not every foreign manufacturer will succeed on a jurisdictional challenge the way the manufacturer did in Fanuc. Evidence that a manufacturer maintained a California sales office, attended California trade shows, negotiated directly with a California buyer, provided direct technical support to a California facility, or customized equipment for the California market can establish the purposeful availment the Fanuc record lacked. Early discovery — including the manufacturer's own sales records, website analytics, and communications — is critical to developing this evidence before a jurisdictional motion is decided.
What to Do After an Industrial Equipment Injury
Whether or not jurisdiction over a foreign manufacturer will ultimately be contested, injured workers and their families should take the following steps as soon as possible:
- Get medical treatment and document injuries thoroughly, including any imaging, surgical records, and long-term prognosis.
- Report the incident to the employer and, where applicable, to Cal/OSHA, which investigates serious workplace equipment injuries and generates records that can become critical evidence.
- Preserve the machine in its post-incident condition if at all possible — do not allow the equipment to be repaired, reprogrammed, or scrapped before it can be inspected by an expert.
- Identify every entity in the chain — manufacturer, importer, distributor, integrator, installer, and maintenance contractor — through purchase orders, service contracts, and equipment nameplates/serial numbers.
- Preserve machine data including fault logs, maintenance records, safety interlock history, and any available control-system data, which is frequently overwritten or purged within weeks.
- Consult a personal injury attorney promptly. Workers' compensation exclusivity does not bar third-party product liability claims, but strict filing deadlines and evidence-preservation windows apply, and jurisdictional disputes like the one in Fanuc can consume significant time if the right defendants and evidence aren't identified at the outset.
How This Fits Into the Broader California Injury Landscape
Industrial equipment injuries often overlap with other categories of Los Angeles personal injury claims our firm handles regularly. A factory robot crush injury may trigger workers' compensation exclusivity questions similar to those we address in third-party workplace injury claims, while a premises-liability angle can arise if the facility itself created additional hazards beyond the machine. If you were hurt in a vehicle collision while transporting goods between facilities, our Los Angeles car accident lawyer team can help. And if your injury happened because of a hazardous walking surface, inadequate lighting, or a fall near defective equipment, our Los Angeles slip-and-fall lawyer guide explains how premises liability claims work alongside a product liability case.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Fanuc v. Superior Court actually decide?
The Fourth District Court of Appeal held that, on the record before it, a California trial court lacked personal jurisdiction over a Japanese industrial robot manufacturer in a lawsuit arising from a bottling-plant injury. The ruling addresses where a company can be sued, not whether the robot was defective or whether anyone was negligent.
Does this mean foreign manufacturers can never be sued in California?
No. Personal jurisdiction is fact-specific. A foreign manufacturer that directly markets, sells, services, or specifically targets the California market can still be subject to suit here. The Fanuc decision turned on the particular distribution and contact evidence in that case, not a blanket rule of immunity.
Who can still be sued if the foreign manufacturer is dismissed?
Often the U.S. distributor, importer, system integrator, installer, employer, or component-part supplier remains within California jurisdiction and may bear independent liability for distribution, installation, maintenance, or warning defects.
What is the stream-of-commerce theory and why didn't it work here?
Stream-of-commerce theories argue a manufacturer should expect its products to reach a state through a distribution chain. Courts require more than mere foreseeability; they look for purposeful availment of the forum state. The appellate panel found the evidentiary record insufficient to show the manufacturer purposefully directed activity at California.
What should an injured worker do immediately after an industrial equipment accident?
Seek medical care, report the incident to the employer, preserve the machine, its control logs, and manuals, identify every entity in the sale and installation chain, and consult a personal injury attorney promptly because workers' compensation exclusivity does not bar third-party product liability claims.
Source: Fanuc Corp. v. Superior Court, published opinion, Fourth Appellate District, filed October 9, 2026. courts.ca.gov/opinion/published/2026-10-09/e086688